Tuesday, March 30, 2010


Hey, isn't this post several years out of date?I really liked "Firefly," and I'm generally the kind of person who pines away forever when a beloved show is cancelled (see: Middleman, JLU, Invisible Man, Eerie Indiana, etc.).

That being said, I don't think I'd want them to bring back "Firefly." And it's all because of "Serenity."

Let's say they picked up where "Serenity" left off: I don't necessarily think the show would be bad, but it certainly wouldn't be the same after the changes "Serenity" made, and I don't think the differences would be for the better. The other option would be to make episodes set before "Serenity," which would always have the Sword of Serenocles hanging above it. Inevitably there'd be winks ahead to what we know is going to happen, and overall it would make the show rather depressing, I think.

Much as I hate to say it, I think we're better off with "Firefly" as a finite entity.

But damn it, bring back the Middleman!


Anthony Strand said...

I agree completely. I've always said that Serenity not only killed Wash, it killed Zoe. Because without him, she'll probably just be an emotionless robot all of the time. He brought out her warm and good-humored side.

Don said...

Well, according to Joss Whedon, the discovery of Miranda, now a part of Serenity, was originally intended to be the third season finale cliffhanger. Which means that the death of the show killed of a long possible future, and folded much of that future into Serenity. I, too, hope it doesn't come back, because it couldn't possibly be what it was intended to be. Also, I think what we have in the 13 extant episodes and the one movie is basically crystallized greatness. If it had gone on longer, it likely wouldn't be as consistently good; look at Buffy season 6 (and, to a lesser extent, 4 and 7). The show is awesome, but there are just long stretches of poor quality TV. I'm glad Firefly never had to go through that.

Anonymous said...

Yeah, Whedon shows that go on too long tend to be subject to "another shocking twist!" and "with sexy results!" style plotting, so I for one am glad we got 13 great episodes (well, 12; I didn't really like the Jubal Early one) and a great movie instead of seeing the show wither into shabbiness like Buffy did. I think it would have been nice to learn a bit more about the characters and their various mysteries, but them's the breaks.